Bad Scrum, but Pretty Good RUP

Most metals have a bit of springiness to them. If you want to bend them to a certain shape, you have to bend them further than that. When they spring back a bit, they’ll take the shape you want.

Today, I was looking at a milestone chart for a project transitioning from a serial lifecycle to an Agile one in a large organization. At first, I despaired at the picture it painted. There are Requirements and Design phases for the release, and a “hardening sprint” before release. Don’t get me wrong. Things are much better than they were before the transition started, but there is quite a way to go before this effort reaches what I would call truly Agile.

Then it struck me.

This is one of the best implementations of RUP I’ve ever witnessed. When I’ve seen organizations adopt RUP, they’ve done so in a very document heavy manner, maintaining all of the gate reviews they had before. In shooting for Agile, this organization has already hit a fairly lightweight version of RUP, eliminating a lot of documentation and gate reviews, and shortening the development iterations and release cycle.

Instead of a struggling Agile adoption I now see a successful RUP adoption. And this is just the beginning; perhaps they’ll reach Agile, yet. That’s not a bad state of affairs.

Post to Twitter Post to Plurk Post to Yahoo Buzz Post to Delicious Post to Digg Post to Facebook Post to MySpace Post to Post to Reddit Post to StumbleUpon

Comments (4) to “Bad Scrum, but Pretty Good RUP”

  1. I like your reframe. /Tobias

  2. IMHO the key thing is that they took a step in a positive direction, not that they were aiming for “agile”. I think they should aim for the sort of organization they want to have, with the capabilities and culture they want, rather than aiming for a popular buzzword.

  3. Ultimately all that matters is do they deliver working software of insanely high quality and delight the customer. If they do a better job today than they did yesterday good for them.

    The real questions:
    – Are they still improving?
    – Do they recognize that they’ve only just started?


  4. Good questions, Mark. In this case, some are, but many have hit a plateau; some do, but many want to think they’ve arrived. They’re still a long way from superlatives, but they are doing a better job today than they did yesterday.

Post a Comment
*Required (Never published)